Federation Commander

mjwest · Posted: Sat Jul 12, 2008 7:25 pm Post subject:

I have kicked both of these up.

For the first question, rather than just guess, I am going to wait for a response.

For the second question, that is indeed what the rule says. While Steve may want to provide a clarification, I am going to stick with this. The two ESGs will indeed interact and not damage the drones, even though this may be counter-intuitive. In this case, it will be better if only one Lyran uses his ESG, while the other relies on tractors or phasers.
_________________

Federation Commander Answer Guy

Davec_24 · Commander Joined: 16 Jul 2008 Posts: 596 Location: England

In terms of using an ESG in multiple modes in a single impulse, 5N2b says:

"Each ESG can be used one (or up to five) times per turn, in any or all of the modes, limited only by the energy contained in the ESG."

While this says "per turn" and not "per impulse", it also says that the use of different modes is limited only by the energy in the capacitor (never mentioning only one mode of use per impulse). The way I read that, it seems like you could use it in the defensive fire phase (say against an incoming drone which has "impacted" a shield during the movement sub-pulses of the impulse) and then again for anti-hellbore and/or an offensive ESG burst in the offensive fire phase of the same impulse, providing you have energy left in the capacitor.

Quite how you would resolve the use of both anti-hellbore *and* an offensive ESG burst in a single offensive fire phase I don't know, though I would guess the hellbore and ESG would interact first, and then if any energy remains after cancelling the hellbore damage would form the offensive ESG burst (resolved in the usual way as per 5N2d). Just speculation, I suppose - one of these cases of "that's how I'd play it" but it doesn't say specifically in the rules about how to resolve a case like that.

mjwest · Posted: Wed Jul 30, 2008 6:32 pm Post subject:

My bad. Forgot to post the eventual rulings. All of these are from Communique #31.

(5N2a) Power used by ESGs must be used in
whole numbers, i.e., two points not two and a half points.
(5N2b) An ESG may only be operated in one mode
in any given Impulse. Within the selected mode, it may
be used multiple times (e.g., you could use anti-hellbore
bursts against multiple hellbore attacks). ESGs cannot
be used in any mode by a ship engaged in Evasive Maneuvers
(2D4).
(5N2d) ESGs cannot use Directed Targeting.
_________________

Federation Commander Answer Guy

mjwest · Posted: Wed Jul 30, 2008 6:51 pm Post subject:

Now, for Kang's last two questions ...

[EDIT: Deleted my wrong answer and question so they wouldn't detract from the right answers give to me by Steve.]
_________________

Federation Commander Answer Guy

mjwest · Posted: Sat Aug 02, 2008 6:54 pm Post subject:

New clarifications from Steve ...

(5N2d) A seeking weapon held in the ship's tractor beam would be damaged by an offensive burst.
(5N2f) In the case of two ships with ESGs in adjacent hexes, the ESGs would damage things in the hex of the respective ship before cancelling each other out. Note, however, that if ship A expended all of its ESG points on targets in its hex, and ship B had ESG damage points remaining after destroying all targets in its hex, the ship B's ESG could damage ship A (depending on the sequence of targets being damaged in (5N2d).
_________________

Federation Commander Answer Guy