Federation Commander

gar1138

Just to confirm (assuming the ADD hits the suicide shuttle in both cases):

ADDs fired defensively at an impacted suicide shuttle will destroy the suicide shuttle immediately (no die roll for damage tot he shuttle).

ADDs fired offensively at suicide shuttles within 2 hexes cause 1d6 damage to the suicide shuttle (ie, they are not necessarily immediately destroyed like they are in defensive fire).

Is this correct? Thanks,

Garrett

Blammo · Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 12:09 pm Post subject:

You have stated it correctly.

mjwest · Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 1:00 pm Post subject:

As Blammo states, yes, that is correct.
_________________

Federation Commander Answer Guy

gar1138 · Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 4:59 pm Post subject:

Thanks, guys. In a recent game, we were confused by the fact that shuttles are affected differently depending on the mode/phase they are hit by ADDs in. It seemed pretty odd, glad we were doing it correctly. Thanks,

Garrett

JonPerry · Lieutenant SG Joined: 12 Jul 2010 Posts: 124

Why the change to ADDs, by the way?

The offensive fire and the firing at SS, I mean.

I thought it was already tough enough to land drone hits on a D5 squadron. Now it is darn near impossible.

mjwest · Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 6:16 pm Post subject:

ericphillips · Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 6:31 pm Post subject:

At first I was not a fan of offensive ADDs, until I played against stingers.

However, I have to say, I do not like the fact that a hit by an ADD kills a shuttle if it hits in the defensive fire phase. I think it should still do d6 damage, just as it does at range one in offensive mode. As you can still back it up with phasers after the ADD, that is okay.

It is a matter of fun. Suicide shuttles rarely strike an opponent, and this rule nerfs them even further. A play example:

Last night in Treasure Ship, my opponent had launched and 18-point suicide shuttle at me. I think I can maneuver away, but he grabs me in a tractor. The SS moves into range 1 and I fire an ADD. Miss.

Next impulse it impacts. I have no phasers on that side, and I brace myself for some damage. I fire the ADD and hit. And the shuttle is gone.

Even as being on the receiving end, I would have preferred rolling damage on the hit against the SS.I would have had to roll "6" to kill it, or take damage, which, when you are done with a game, is something to talk about ("I can't believe you rolled a 6 to take out my shuttle!!").

To point out, under Rev. 5 rules, the thing would have automatically hit for damage, as I ha nothing on that side to fire, and ADDs didn't work against shuttles.

Blammo · Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 7:12 pm Post subject:

ericphillips · Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 7:41 pm Post subject:

Yeah, and as much as I point out FC is FC and SFB is a different game for making rules, the reason range 1 is used for defensive fire rolls is because in SFB if a seeking weapon gets to range 0, it hits. You need to fire at it at range 1 or longer. At range 1 in SFB, the ADD hit on a shuttle does d6 damage. There is no autokill.

JonPerry · Lieutenant SG Joined: 12 Jul 2010 Posts: 124

I completely agree re:autokill on SS

ericphillips · Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 8:22 pm Post subject:

You agree YES to autokill or NO to autokill?

duxvolantis · Lieutenant SG Joined: 16 Nov 2010 Posts: 185

Nerroth · Posted: Thu Mar 17, 2011 5:19 am Post subject:

I agree, it should be a d6 for shuttles.

In SFB, the whole reason the FRA converted the anti-drone into the short-range cannon was because ADDs treat tachyon missiles as shuttles, not as drones (while SRCs treat them as drones instead). In FC, ADDs shouldn't be able to effectively autokill a TM, else the defensive niche the SRC is supposed to fill would be made moot.
_________________
FC Omega Discussion (v3)
FC LMC Discussion

JonPerry · Lieutenant SG Joined: 12 Jul 2010 Posts: 124

I could have been more clear.

I do not like autokilling shuttles with an ADD.

JimDauphinais · Posted: Thu Mar 17, 2011 1:37 pm Post subject:

I raised a question about the difference regarding ADD Offensive Fire and Defensive Fire versus shuttles when RRB6b was being worked on to make sure the difference was intended. The rule wasn't changed. So, apparently it is intended and there must be a reason why Defensive Fire by an ADD versus shuttles is an auto kill when the ADD roll is successful.
_________________
Jim Dauphinais, Chesterfield, MO

St. Louis Area Fed Comm Group: http://games.groups.yahoo.com/group/STL_Federation_Commander/