SFB Rules Q&A

Star Fleet Universe Discussion Board: Star Fleet Battles: Rules Questions: SFB Rules Q&A
  Subtopic Posts   Updated
Archive through July 22, 2017  25   07/22 12:15am
Archive through September 11, 2017  25   09/11 12:27am
Archive through November 21, 2017  25   11/21 04:25pm
Archive through December 28, 2017  25   12/28 07:14pm
Archive through February 09, 2018  25   02/09 09:16am
Archive through February 26, 2018  25   02/26 06:00pm
Archive through March 02, 2018  25   03/02 02:10pm
Archive through March 19, 2018  25   03/19 03:04pm
Archive through March 23, 2018  25   03/23 04:37am
Archive through April 10, 2018  25   04/10 02:21pm
Archive through April 23, 2018  25   04/23 06:20pm
Archive through May 30, 2018  25   05/30 06:21am
Archive through July 03, 2018  25   07/03 09:37pm
Archive through July 24, 2018  25   07/24 09:46pm
Archive through March 07, 2011  0    
Archive through August 13, 2018  25   08/14 12:30am
Archive through August 17, 2018  25   08/18 12:30am
Archive through August 19, 2018  25   08/20 11:24am
Archive through September 02, 2018  25   09/06 11:11pm
Archive through September 27, 2018  25   09/27 10:27pm
Archive through November 15, 2018  25   11/17 05:52pm
Archive through November 28, 2018  25   11/28 09:09pm
Archive through January 15, 2019  25   01/19 05:35pm
Archive through March 04, 2019  25   03/04 04:36pm
Archive through March 13, 2019  25   03/14 08:45pm
Archive through March 25, 2019  25   03/27 03:11am
Archive through April 03, 2019  25   04/05 08:09pm
Archive through April 12, 2019  25   04/13 11:11am
Archive through May 30, 2019  25   05/31 05:15am
Archive through June 16, 2019  25   06/17 08:09pm
Archive through July 03, 2019  25   07/11 08:15am
Archive through August 07, 2019  25   08/08 03:20pm
Archive through August 15, 2019  25   08/22 05:48pm
Archive through August 26, 2019  25   08/30 01:14pm
Archive through September 24, 2019  25   09/25 07:05pm
Archive through September 27, 2019  25   09/27 08:20pm
Archive through October 15, 2019  25   10/17 03:05am
Archive through October 28, 2019  25   10/28 04:40pm
Archive through October 29, 2019  25   11/02 12:18pm
Archive through November 17, 2019  25   11/18 03:32pm
Archive through December 14, 2019  25   12/22 02:27am
Archive through December 30, 2019  25   12/31 05:15pm
Archive through January 14, 2020  25   01/15 02:12pm
Archive through January 21, 2020  25   01/22 07:04pm
Archive through January 26, 2020  25   01/29 05:19pm
Archive through February 14, 2020  25   02/19 05:05am
Archive through March 05, 2020  25   03/07 12:57pm
Archive through March 12, 2020  25   03/12 08:31pm
Archive through March 24, 2020  25   03/24 04:13pm
Archive through April 08, 2020  25   04/08 03:55pm
Archive through April 09, 2020  25   04/09 11:34am
Archive through April 09, 2020  25   04/09 06:41pm
Archive through April 16, 2020  25   04/17 01:51pm
Archive through April 28, 2020  25   04/29 03:18pm
Archive through May 04, 2020  25   05/04 09:52pm
Archive through May 07, 2020  25   05/08 05:46pm
Archive through May 13, 2020  25   05/15 01:37am
Archive through June 09, 2020  25   06/11 10:22pm
Archive through June 13, 2020  25   06/13 08:52pm
Archive through June 27, 2020  25   06/28 09:42am
Archive through July 07, 2020  25   07/07 07:04pm
Archive through July 26, 2020  25   07/27 07:06pm
Archive through July 29, 2020  25   07/30 09:21am
Archive through August 04, 2020  25   08/05 08:08pm
Archive through August 06, 2020  25   08/07 06:47pm
Archive through August 28, 2020  25   08/28 06:25pm
Archive through September 07, 2020  25   09/08 02:09pm
Archive through September 18, 2020  25   09/18 06:42pm
Archive through September 28, 2020  25   09/29 04:18pm
Archive through October 22, 2020  25   10/22 11:42am
Archive through November 16, 2020  25   11/17 12:56pm
Archive through November 30, 2020  25   12/04 08:33am
Archive through December 12, 2020  25   12/16 05:05pm
Archive through January 06, 2021  25   01/07 07:45am
Archive through January 10, 2021  25   01/14 06:08pm
Archive through January 25, 2021  25   01/27 06:33pm
Archive through February 01, 2021  25   02/04 11:03am
Archive through February 08, 2021  25   02/10 05:14pm
Archive through February 11, 2021  25   02/12 10:26am
Archive through February 12, 2021  25   02/12 11:33pm
Archive through February 13, 2021  25   02/15 02:14pm
Archive through March 05, 2021  25   03/06 08:18pm
Archive through April 04, 2021  25   04/05 06:27pm
Archive through April 11, 2021  25   04/12 07:27pm
Archive through April 22, 2021  25   04/27 02:29pm
Archive through May 04, 2021  25   05/04 06:48pm
Archive through May 07, 2021  25   05/08 08:26am
Archive through May 20, 2021  25   05/20 08:32pm
Archive through May 26, 2021  25   05/30 02:56pm
Archive through June 10, 2021  25   06/10 10:40pm
Archive through June 23, 2021  25   06/23 07:19pm
Archive through July 25, 2021  25   07/25 05:44pm
Archive through August 03, 2021  25   08/04 04:05pm
Archive through August 09, 2021  25   08/10 07:32pm
Archive through August 12, 2021  25   08/12 07:44pm
Archive through August 31, 2021  25   09/16 01:34pm
Archive through October 08, 2021  25   10/08 11:59pm
Archive through October 14, 2021  25   10/14 04:48pm
Archive through October 20, 2021  25   10/21 09:59am
Archive through November 09, 2021  25   11/11 02:18pm
Archive through December 02, 2021  25   12/02 03:28pm
Archive through December 10, 2021  25   12/19 08:11am
Archive through January 08, 2022  25   01/09 12:58pm
Archive through January 31, 2022  25   02/03 04:41am
Archive through April 12, 2022  25   04/17 11:29am
Archive through April 26, 2022  25   04/30 01:42pm
Archive through May 08, 2022  25   05/09 03:41am
Archive through June 09, 2022  25   07/09 06:06pm
Archive through July 17, 2022  25   07/19 01:39pm
Archive through August 15, 2022  25   08/19 07:39am
Archive through September 27, 2022  25   10/05 09:44pm
Archive through October 11, 2022  25   10/12 12:26am
Archive through October 16, 2022  25   10/22 09:53am
Archive through November 13, 2022  25   11/14 01:51pm
Archive through January 09, 2023  25   01/09 10:46pm
Archive through February 13, 2023  25   02/17 02:41pm
Archive through March 02, 2023  25   03/04 03:23pm
Archive through March 10, 2023  25   03/10 04:56pm
Archive through March 28, 2023  25   03/30 07:05pm
Archive through April 09, 2023  25   04/11 12:46pm
Archive through April 14, 2023  25   05/06 05:16pm
Archive through May 11, 2023  25   05/12 06:18pm
Archive through May 30, 2023  25   06/12 01:08am
Archive through June 28, 2023  25   07/26 11:19pm
Archive through August 10, 2023  25   08/14 01:32pm
Archive through August 21, 2023  25   08/22 02:32pm
Archive through August 27, 2023  25   08/31 05:05pm
Archive through September 16, 2023  25   09/21 11:50pm
Archive through October 02, 2023  25   10/09 12:31pm
Archive through November 01, 2023  25   11/10 10:05am
Archive through January 13, 2024  25   01/28 05:49am
Archive through April 14, 2024  25   05/02 05:28pm
Archive through June 17, 2024  25   06/22 06:38pm
Archive through August 23, 2024  25   08/25 10:21am
Archive through September 11, 2024  25   09/12 01:20pm
Archive through October 18, 2024  25   10/19 09:19am
Archive through October 26, 2024  25   10/28 06:09pm
Archive through November 07, 2024  25   11/14 09:27pm
Archive through January 28, 2025  25   01/30 09:11am
Archive through March 17, 2025  25   03/26 12:43pm
Archive through May 12, 2025  25   05/15 10:29am
Archive through June 09, 2025  25   06/25 10:48am
Archive through October 01, 2025  26   10/29 05:56pm
Archive through November 24, 2025  25   11/24 08:17pm
Archive through November 28, 2025  25   12/14 09:12am
Archive through April 05, 2026  25   04/14 08:29am
Archive through April 28, 2026  25   06/17 02:37pm
Archive through September 02, 2026  25   09/03 07:13pm
Archive through October 05, 2026  25   10/20 04:21pm

Please note: Omega-based questions go in the Omega Q&A; Magellanic-based questions go in the The Magellanic Cloud Q&A.

Authors, please note that if you have a rules question pertaining to a story, such questions are always carried out through email
By John Malis (Jmalis) on Monday, October 05, 2026 - 01:58 pm: Edit

Cool Beans! Thank you Jessica.

By Frank Lemay (Princeton) on Monday, October 05, 2026 - 02:07 pm: Edit

Reposting my question re ecm dronemovement.
Seeking weapon HETS

Situation: A Ship is facing B has a speed 32 ECM drone and starts the turn at 0.
It does two tac TACs to facing D.
The ships will be accelerating to speed 10 later in the turn.
Since the ship will have to go forward, he has the ECM drone HET to facing D in impulse 8 to align with the ship. The ship then accelerate to speed 10 in impulse 10 and moves a hex.

Rules
(F2.136) A seeking weapon could make an HET on an impulse when it is not scheduled to move; the weapon would then skip its next scheduled movement.

(FD9.182) HET: If the protected unit executes an HET, the ECM drone can do so as well, but this costs it the equivalent of a hex of speed, and unless the ship is moving at least one hex per turn slower than the maximum rated speed of the ECM drone, the drone will not be able to move on the next impulse the ship moves. If an ECM drone is moving less than its maximum speed, and performs an HET on an impulse it was not scheduled to move, it will not lose its next movement. The drone can only perform one HET in any 32-impulse period (F2.13), and if the target unit executes a second HET, the drone will not be able to follow it and will be forced to execute a normal turn to try to catch up.

The shipped did not technically HET; does FD9.182 still apply as the ECM drone did a HET in a prior impulse to its scheduled move and is moving to keep station with the ship in impulse 10 (its next scheduled move with the speed change).
When the ship moves on impulse 10, does the ecm drone keep station in impulse 10 per the later half of FD9.182 or does it not move as this is the first scheduled move per F2.136,

Thanks.

Cheers
Frank

By Steve Petrick (Petrick) on Monday, October 19, 2026 - 03:37 pm: Edit

Frank Lemay:

My apologies for not answering sooner, but between my own illness of late and problems around the office I have not had a chance to even look at your question. I have downloaded it and will try to have an answer up soon,

Steven P.

By Steve Petrick (Petrick) on Tuesday, October 20, 2026 - 03:03 pm: Edit

Frank Lemay asked: Situation: A Ship is facing B has a Speed 32 ECM drone and starts the turn at Speed 0.
It does two tac TACs to facing D.
The ship will be accelerating to Speed 10 later in the turn.
Since the ship will have to go forward, he has the ECM drone HET to facing D in Impulse #8 to align with the ship. The ship then accelerates to Speed 10 in Impulse #10 and moves a hex.

ANSWER: While not specifically stated in the rules, a ship moving Speed 0 with an ECM drone lending it ECM in its hex will also have the drone moving Speed 0, and if the ship performs a TAC, whether from warp energy or impulse energy, on any given impulse to change its facing, the drone will also change its facing on the impulse to stay with the ship. This is not a HET, but if the ship were to perform a HET and accelerate to leave the hex, the drone could only maintain facing if. It also did a HET. This would only be a problem if the ship left the hex on the same impulse it used the HET, or if the drone was slow speed and the ship accelerated faster than the drone could HET and move after it (F2.136). The drone always moves AFTER its target, and so could Not anticipate the ship’s HET, but could react to it.

By Frank Lemay (Princeton) on Tuesday, October 20, 2026 - 04:21 pm: Edit

SPP,
Thanks and hope you're feeling better.

That is how we played it !

Cheers
Frank

By Steve Petrick (Petrick) on Wednesday, October 21, 2026 - 02:36 pm: Edit

Thanks to Frank Lemay.

By David Hanson (Glimaash) on Friday, November 06, 2026 - 02:19 pm: Edit

A P/F flotilla starts the turn on a Ground P/F base (GPF). They plot power to take off from their landing pad. P2.4121 (Take off Procedures) states the flotilla will not leave the planet until impulse #32. Can the flotilla fire their weapons as a landed ship per P2.53 (Firing from a planet) before impulse 32?

Thanks


Add a Message


This is a private posting area. A valid username and password combination is required to post messages to this discussion.
Username:  
Password:

Administrator's Control Panel -- Board Moderators Only
Administer Page | Delete Conversation | Close Conversation | Move Conversation