Archive through April 08, 2006

Star Fleet Universe Discussion Board: Federation & Empire: F&E INPUT: F&E Scenario Proposals: Update to the F&E2K Scenario (602.0): The Tempest: Archive through April 08, 2006
By James Lowry (Rindis) on Tuesday, April 04, 2006 - 10:17 pm: Edit

Lyran 602.5 OOB:
RaceUnit Hulls #UnitEP ValueAdj AF
In Kzinti space
Lyran1DN1612
Lyran3CA88
Lyran3CL66
Lyran3CW57
Lyran3DW46
Lyran6DD55
Lyran6FF2.54
Lyran1TGC88
Lyran1MB109
In Lyran space
Lyran1CL66
Lyran1DD55
Lyran2FF2.54
Lyran2FRD101
Lyran1TGP64
Lyran1TGC88
Lyran1MB109
In Klingon space
Lyran1CC99
Lyran3CW57
Lyran3CL66
Lyran1SC74
In Hydran space
Lyran1DN1612
Lyran1BC1010
Lyran1CC99
Lyran3CA88
Lyran12CW57
Lyran12DW46
Lyran12FF2.54
Lyran1TGP64
Lyran1CVL1910
Lyran1CWE67
Lyran1DWE56
Lyran1SC74
Lyran1MB109
GHQ
Lyran2DN1612
Lyran2BC1010
Lyran1CC99
Lyran3CA88
Lyran3CW57
Lyran3CL66
Lyran3DW46
Lyran3FF2.54
Lyran1CVL1910
Lyran1CWE67
Lyran1DWE56
Lyran1STT1010
Lyran2SC74

Notes: GHQ is given as 'Forces in any of above (except Klingon):'
* The Lyrans are listed as having 3xSC and nothing heavier. This might make sense in 'basic' F&E, but seems unlikely given the EW comments that accompany the Hydran scouts in AO. It seems likely to add one or more DWs to the mix.
* R11.27 (R3) indicates that there was one CWS prototype constructed in Y168 (which has never been shown in F&E) with regular production starting in Y172.

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Wednesday, April 05, 2006 - 12:00 am: Edit

Klingons
in Kzinti SpaceUNIT HULLS #UNITEP VALUEAF
Klingons1C81612
Klingons2D7C99
Klingons6D788
Klingons3D687
Klingons5D6D119
Klingons2D6M1010
Klingons12D557
Klingons2D5S85
Klingons5F5L46
Klingons10F535
Klingons9E42.54
Klingons2F5S43
Klingons1D6V1812
Klingons1D7V2213
Klingons1D5V1912
Klingons3FV128
Klingons2AD566
Klingons2F5E44
Klingons5E4A3.52
Klingons1TGA88
Klingons1FRD101
Klingons1MB100
in Klingon Space
Klingons1C81612
Klingons1D7C99
Klingons3D788
Klingons3D687
Klingons1D6D119
Klingons1D6M1010
Klingons18D557
Klingons2F5L86
Klingons4F545
Klingons1FV128
Klingons1E4A3.52
Klingons1TGB84
Klingons1FRD101
Klingons2MB100
In Hydran Space
Klingons1C81612
Klingons2D7C99
Klingons3D788
Klingons6D687
Klingons2D6D119
Klingons1D6M1010
Klingons9D557
Klingons5F5L46
Klingons10F535
Klingons12E42.54
Klingons4F5S43
Klingons1D7V2213
Klingons1D5V1912
Klingons1FV128
Klingons1AD566
Klingons1F5E44
Klingons1E4A3.52
Klingons1TGA88
Klingons1TGB64
Klingons1FRD101
Klingons1MB100
GHQ
Klingons1C81612
Klingons2D788
Klingons3D687
Klingons3D557
Klingons5F5L46
Klingons10F535
Klingons6E42.54
Klingons1F5S43
Klingons2FV128
Klingons2E4A3.52
Klingons1MB100
Mothball
Klingons12D687

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Wednesday, April 05, 2006 - 12:01 am: Edit

Chuck, I also have some ship counts tabulated for the Klingons if you want them for totals that could be potentially be built from at start forces and the build scedule if you need that let me know.

By Chuck Strong (Raider) on Wednesday, April 05, 2006 - 02:55 am: Edit

Mike:

Sure -- if you got it. Just keep them as base hulls (no variants) as this would be the upper limit (assumes no overbuilds) on that type of base hull.

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Wednesday, April 05, 2006 - 07:22 am: Edit

That is what I have done. It will be posted later today.

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Wednesday, April 05, 2006 - 09:48 pm: Edit

Here is the starting Klingon forces and their max build/activiations for turns 1-6

MaxBuildStartTurn 1Turn 2Turn 3Turn 4Turn 5Turn 6TOTAL
C821115
D7C711110
D72112121230
D62111124
D6M33
D6D33
D5399999957
F5L1922222231
F53844444462
E42433333342
D6V33
CVT33
FV77
E4A1919
FRD33
MB44
fff612121242
CO
D7A1
SAV3
D6S2
LAV2
FTL2
FTS3
D6G3
F5G3
AO
F5J4
ADM6
FD73
D6J3
C52
SAF3
GENERAL
BP4
DP2
VP24
MA
MON3
T-POD4
MOTHBALL
D62422222212
F51222222212
E412333312

By Chuck Strong (Raider) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 03:45 am: Edit

Here's the tally so far:

Ship HullsUnitsEP Value Total EPsAdj AFTotal AF
Klingon2K4C816.064.01248
Klingon2K5D7C9.045.0945
Klingon2K14D78.0112.08112
Klingon2K2D7V22.044.01326
Klingon2K15D68.0120.07105
Klingon2K8D6D11.088.0972
Klingon2K4D6M10.040.01040
Klingon2K1D6V18.018.01212
Klingon2K42D55.0210.07294
Klingon2K2D5V19.038.01224
Klingon2K3AD56.018.0618
Klingon2K2D5S8.016.0510
Klingon2K17F5L4.068.06102
Klingon2K34F53.0102.05170
Klingon2K7FV12.084.0856
Klingon2K3F5E4.012.0412
Klingon2K7F5S4.028.0321
Klingon2K27E42.567.54108
Klingon2K9E4A3.531.5218
Klingon2K2TGA8.016.0816
Klingon2K2TGB8.016.048
Klingon2K3FRD10.030.013
Klingon2K0.00
Klingon2K4VP26.024.028
Klingon2K2DP6.012.036
Klingon2K4BP4.016.028
2231320.01342
.
Ship HullsUnitsEP Value Total EPsAdj AFTotal AF
Lyran2K4DN16.064.01248
Lyran2K1STT10.010.01010
Lyran2K2CVL19.038.01020
Lyran2K3BC10.030.01030
Lyran2K3CC9.027.0927
Lyran2K9CA8.072.0872
Lyran2K2CWE6.012.0714
Lyran2K21CW5.0105.07147
Lyran2K2DWE5.010.0612
Lyran2K18DW4.072.06108
Lyran2K10CL6.060.0660
Lyran2K7DD5.035.0535
Lyran2K4SC7.028.0416
Lyran2K23FF2.557.5492
Lyran2K2TGC8.016.0816
Lyran2K2TGP6.012.048
Lyran2K2FRD10.020.012
Lyran2K0.00
Lyran2K0.00
Lyran2K0.00
Lyran2K2BP4.08.048
117676.5725
.
Ship HullsUnitsEP Value Total EPsAdj AFTotal AF
Hydran2K2PAL22.044.01734
Hydran2K1LB11.011.01111
Hydran2K1LM11.011.01111
Hydran2K4DG10.040.01144
Hydran2K10RN10.0100.010100
Hydran2K1CV32.032.01414
Hydran2K1UH24.024.01010
Hydran2K4HR8.032.0832
Hydran2K2DE8.016.0714
Hydran2K1TR5.05.077
Hydran2K2KN6.012.0612
Hydran2K5LN6.030.0630
Hydran2K2TG12.024.0510
Hydran2K2CR3.57.0510
Hydran2K3CU2.57.5412
Hydran2K4AH3.514.0312
Hydran2K3SC3.510.539
Hydran2K3HN2.57.539
Hydran2K1FRD10.010.011
Hydran2K2VP14.028.0612
Hydran2K2BP10.020.0918
56485.5412

Note: I left off the MBs and mothballs for now and added the Pods.

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 04:41 pm: Edit

Chuck, do you want the same chart I did on the Klingons turns 1-6 for the Kzinti and Lyrans?

By Christopher E. Fant (Cfant) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 04:48 pm: Edit

Sorry CHuck, I was hoping to have some extra time to work on this, but it turns out I will not. Sorry guys.

By Chuck Strong (Raider) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 06:52 pm: Edit

Mike: Yes -- thanks.

Chris: Understand.

Team: Can one of you post the Kzinti OOB chart?

Thanks.

By John Robinson (John_R) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 09:16 pm: Edit

Chuck - Where did you find info on pods?

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 09:25 pm: Edit

Lyran force breakdown with max standard hull construction:

ShipStart123456Total 1-6Total All
DN111134
BC211135
CC404
CA15111111621
CW114444442435
CL18018
DW43333331822
DD18018
FF183333331836
SC404
TGC202
TGP202
FRD202
BP
CO
SAV2
LAV1
DDG5
FTL1
FTS2
SAF1
MON2
AP1
TP2
AO
CF2
JGP1
FF3
DD3
DNL1
SP1

By John Robinson (John_R) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 09:33 pm: Edit

Ship HullsUnitsEP ValueAdj AF
Kzinti2K2DN1612
Kzinti2K3CC99
Kzinti2K11BC88
Kzinti2K12CM57
Kzinti2K3DD66
Kzinti2K1CL66
Kzinti2K7DF4.54
Kzinti2K18FF2.54
Kzinti2K6CV2416
Kzinti2K11MEC66
Kzinti2K16EFF3.52
Kzinti2K5CVL1812
Kzinti2K5CVE149
Kzinti2K2TGT68
Kzinti2K1TGC84
Kzinti2K4SF3.53
Kzinti2K1FRD101
108

By John Robinson (John_R) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 09:36 pm: Edit

Mike - Are you using the OOB from 2K or AO?

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 09:48 pm: Edit

Kzinti at start forces plus max builds:
ShipsSTART123456TURNS 1-6TOTAL
DN21124
CC505
BC15111111621
CM224241414
CL8111311
DD31236
FF62356562733
DF505
SF505
TGC202
TGT303
FRD202
CV51127
CVL404
CVE505
MEC1122
CLE505
EFF1411216
VP606
BP404
CVW/CO
CD1
SDF1
LAV2
SAV3
FTL1
FTS2
CLG2
FFG3
MON3
TPOD4
AO
DNL2
BF2
DDV1
DD3
FFK3
FF1
FCR2
LAD1
SAD1
LAS1
SAS1
SP2

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 10:08 pm: Edit

duplicate of John Robinsons post on the Kzinti

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 10:08 pm: Edit

Chuck, What else do you need?

By Mike Curtis (Nashvillen) on Thursday, April 06, 2006 - 10:12 pm: Edit

John, I used 2K for the at start forces for the OOB for the 602

I used AO OOB for turn 1 at start forces and builds.

By Chuck Strong (Raider) on Friday, April 07, 2006 - 03:11 am: Edit

Kzinti tally:

RACEUnit HullsUnitsEP Value Total EPsAdj AFTotal AF
Kzinti2K2DN16.032.01224
Kzinti2K6CV24.0144.01696
Kzinti2K5CVL18.090.01260
Kzinti2K5CVE14.070.0945
Kzinti2K3CC9.027.0618
Kzinti2K11BC8.088.0222
Kzinti2K12CM5.060.09108
Kzinti2K11MEC6.066.0888
Kzinti2K16EFF3.556.0696
Kzinti2K1CL6.06.077
Kzinti2K3DD6.018.0618
Kzinti2K18FF2.545.0472
Kzinti2K7DF4.531.5428
Kzinti2K4SF3.514.0312
Kzinti2K2TGC8.016.048
Kzinti2K1TGT6.06.088
Kzinti2K1FRD10.010.011
Kzinti2K6VP7.042.0318
Kzinti2K4BP6.024.028
118845.5737

By Chuck Strong (Raider) on Friday, April 07, 2006 - 03:15 am: Edit

Now that I have posted the F&E2K OOB in my balance sheet will someone double check my posted tallies -- I did find a few errors but most were on target. Thanks.

By John Robinson (John_R) on Friday, April 07, 2006 - 08:02 am: Edit

I found a few errors in the Kzinti table.

I reversed some of the data on the TGT and TGC. The TGT should be AF 4 and Total AF 8. The TGC should be AF 8 and Total AF 8.

The AF and Total AF for the CC are wrong. They should be 9 and 27 respectively.

The AF and Total AF for the BC are wrong. They should be 8 and 88 respectively.

The AF and Total AF for the CM are wrong. They should be 7 and 84 respectively.

The AF and Total AF for the CL are wrong. They should be 6 and 6 respectively.

The AF and Total AF for the MEC are wrong. They should be 6 and 66 respectively.

The AF and Total AF for the EFF are wrong. They should be 2 and 32 respectively.

I am posting my version of your table below.

Ship HullsUnitsEP ValueTotal EPsAdj AFTotal AF
Kzinti2K2DN16321224
Kzinti2K3CC927927
Kzinti2K11BC888888
Kzinti2K12CM560784
Kzinti2K3DD618618
Kzinti2K1CL6666
Kzinti2K7DF4.531.5428
Kzinti2K18FF2.545472
Kzinti2K6CV241441696
Kzinti2K11MEC666666
Kzinti2K16EFF3.556232
Kzinti2K5CVL18901260
Kzinti2K5CVE1470945
Kzinti2K2TGT61248
Kzinti2K1TGC8888
Kzinti2K4SF3.514312
Kzinti2K1FRD101011
Kzinti2K6VP742318
Kzinti2K4BP62428
118843.5701

By Chuck Strong (Raider) on Saturday, April 08, 2006 - 05:21 pm: Edit

Well I can see we already have some of the same incongruencies with the historical OOB and the max build schedule as I had with Hurricane:

The OOB lists 23 CM hulls available (23CM + 11MEC) but the turn-1 at start plus max build schedule only allows for 16 CM hulls; we are going to have to find replacement hulls for at least 7 CM hulls as a result.

So here is what I need...

Someone go through and review the OOB tallies I loaded above and check them against Mike's max hulls chart and report any incongruencies here. If you only want to report on just one race then that would work also. Thanks.

By John Robinson (John_R) on Saturday, April 08, 2006 - 05:49 pm: Edit

I'll take the Kzinti. Some of the CM/MEC can be resolved by replacing them with the CLEs put in the OOB in AO.

By Chuck Strong (Raider) on Saturday, April 08, 2006 - 06:13 pm: Edit

Here's my quick-look fix:

Max historical hulls types: 16CL (CL/CLD/CLE) [ignoring the 5CVE hulls] + 16CM (CM/MEC)

OOB as is: 1CL + 12CM + 11MEC = 24
2K Fix: 8CL + 5CM + 4CL(escorts) + 7MEC = 24
AO Fix: 3CL + 5CLD + 5CM + 4CLE + 7MEC = 24

By Ryan Opel (Ryan) on Saturday, April 08, 2006 - 06:20 pm: Edit

I'll do the Hydrans and post the max build in a couple of hours when I get home from work.

Administrator's Control Panel -- Board Moderators Only
Administer Page | Delete Conversation | Close Conversation | Move Conversation